There’s No Place Like Home by Joseph Finlay
May 7, 2009 by Joseph Finlay
Filed under Opinion
Surely we’re all multiculturists now. We accept the necessity of the pluralist democratic state, with multiple groups sharing a contested yet neutral public space. We know, as children of modernity, that we can never be fully ‘at home’, that communities are virtual, free flowing and in flux, and that identities are multiple. We know, from the tradition of post-colonial thought that homelands are always ‘imagined’. We know these things as a society, at least in part, because Jews have taught them to us. As the pioneers of the modern project, Jewish ‘rootless cosmopolitans’ were instrumental in creating a world where the borders of nation states were transcended and internationalism became a defining value.



so you’re okay with connecting ethnocentrically to Judaism just so long as it’s universalist?
I’m not sure I understand your point. I argue against an ethnocentric connection to Judaism. Certainly I have a connection to past Jewish communities that is in patt ethnic, but I think that we would be better off theorising Jewish communities as communities of practice, rather than a people glued together by common descent.